By Height By Weight  

Bulking or Cutting: Understanding a Reddit User's Weight Journey

A 21-year-old user on Reddit looks for advice on whether to bulk up or cut weight. A scientific article discussing the advice given by others while not encouraging a visit to the Reddit thread

Article by Madeleine Smith

A before and after photo of a 5'8" male showing a snapshot of 160 pounds at a height of 5'8
M/21/5'8 160. BulkorCut is pretty dead and I was just looking for some advice. Do you guys think I should pack on more muscle or just cut?
Originally posted on /r/Brogress

Introduction

One of the biggest challenges of people into fitness is knowing whether to bulk or cut weight. Anyone who has had an experience understands that it is a choice that may be tough at times. In this article, we use a reddit user's post to examine the advice given to help him make an informed decision.

Reddit User's Dilemma

The Reddit user, “shallhebulkorcut,” posted a question on whether he should bulk up more or cut. Having a body weight of 160lbs, 21 years old and 5’8”, he required advice to help him make a decision. The post garnered 18 upvotes, with four other Reddit users offering responses.

Different opinions on cutting or bulking

Some of the advice given to the Reddit user proposed that he should cut. One user, Jax_Masterson, felt that the benefits of looking lean in the summer were worth a cut. Additionally, another user, MortifiedCucumber, felt that a cut would be excellent for this user because, according to them, he already looked good. On the other hand, other advice given was that the user should focus more on building mass rather than cutting because the user looked like he had more mass to add.

What the User has to Say

The Reddit user wanted to bulk up more but was not sure whether he should cut instead. His main goal is to become bigger, but he also thinks that cutting can improve his aesthetics. He wondered whether he had enough size to cut, something which MortifiedCucumber felt he already had. To know whether he needed to bulk or cut, he also added his workouts and strength levels.

Final Words

The user's case is an excellent example of how subjective bulking and cutting are. The decision should primarily depend on one's reasons for working out and what they want to achieve. Finally, it is essential for people to be creative enough to find what works for them in their fitness journey.

Comments
No comments found! Be the first!

Madeleine Smith

Content Lead at MyProgressPics.com

Madeleine is passionate about empowering individuals with the information and tools they need to transform their bodies and lives.